Kenya’s healthcare system, education sector and governance structures have come under scrutiny, with civic rights activist Allans Ademba and former Cabinet Minister Kipruto Arap Kirwa calling for accountability, institutional reforms and evidence-based policymaking.
The two leaders questioned the effectiveness of the Social Health Authority (SHA), the sustainability of education policies and the country’s approach to leadership and governance, arguing that Kenya’s development should be measured by tangible results rather than registration figures, policy announcements and political promises.
Their concerns centred on three critical areas: healthcare, education, and leadership and governance.
HEALTH:
Civic rights activist Allans Ademba has challenged the government to demonstrate whether the Social Health Authority (SHA) is delivering meaningful healthcare services to Kenyans, arguing that its success should not be measured by the number of people registered but by those who can access treatment.
Ademba maintained that healthcare should be universal, accessible and equitable, regardless of an individual’s economic background, warning against a system where access to medical services is determined by membership cards or financial capacity.
“SHA needs to be universal.
Health care should not be about membership card, it should be universal, accessible, equitable and it should work for everyone despite your economic background.
When we talk about SHA , are we going to measure workability or the need to have SHA because it has registered 32 million people or because it’s working for 32 million people?,let’s assess SHA through not the number of people registered but the people the people who got covered and walked out.
SHA needs to be universal,can 3600/= cover a jua Kali person’s health”
He also raised concerns about the affordability of the proposed Sh3,600 contribution, particularly for the jua kali workers.
Former Cabinet Minister Kipruto Arap Kirwa, meanwhile, questioned the rationale behind replacing the National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) with SHA, arguing that changing the system without addressing its fundamental weaknesses could undermine the intended reforms.
Kirwa maintained that the government had not adequately explained the fundamental reasons for abandoning NHIF or demonstrated how the new system would address the challenges that existed under the previous arrangement.
“When I keep on explaining the failures of this government I will be mistaken to be in government because at first place, we should have not changed from NHIF to SHA,by changing from the system of NHIF to SHA without changing the fundamentals.
We never gave any fundamentals reasons why we had to change because from changing from that system to this without changing the fundamentals,this is key in organizational analysis because it will tell what was fundamentally wrong and the need to change the software rather than just changing the name,”
Kirwa further challenged the government to move beyond national healthcare statistics and examine the actual capacity of health facilities, including the availability of doctors and nurses.
“NHIF was here before, don’t talk about empty statistics.what is the doctor patient ratio in bungoma county , what’s the issue of the nurse patient ratio in the same county and when you talk about hospitals how many of them are run by the state,how many are runned by faith based organisations like missions and catholic Church so that when you are talking about overall health you are just talking of empty statistics.
Education and health care tie,what is the foundation you gave a child you said is going to do nursing in certain MTC ,what are the fundamental behavior that you’re able to instill in a child leaving alliance highschool,kamsinga boys or mang’u”
EDUCATION:
Ademba Warns of Underinvestment as Kirwa Questions Policy Changes
Kenya’s education sector is also facing questions over funding, institutional sustainability and the ability of universities and other learning institutions to produce graduates equipped to address the country’s economic challenges.
Ademba warned that the country risks undermining its ambition of building a competitive economy by underinvesting in institutions responsible for producing knowledge and developing human capital.
Citing the challenges facing universities, including lecturers’ strikes and concerns over the funding model, he argued that the country must rethink how it measures success in education.
Ademba claimed that Kenya was achieving only five per cent of what it should be delivering in the education sector, questioning the priorities guiding government investment.
“We are at 5% of what we are supposed to be achieving in education.
We can’t talk of a competitive economy and we are under- investing in the system that is supposed to produce knowledge in the universities, colleges, secondary and primary schools.
Education is supposed to be an equalizer,we need to assess the new funding model.
How are we measuring success?Are we measuring success by the degrees produced in a year or are we measuring success by the number of problems solved as the degrees provided this year?
We are all entering the market but the market is not ready to accommodate us.”
He argued that education should be an equaliser and that the effectiveness of the education system should be measured by the solutions graduates bring to society rather than simply the number of degrees awarded annually.
Former Cabinet Minister Kipruto Arap Kirwa questioned the financial challenges facing universities, arguing that government policy changes must be informed by research, proper planning and realistic assessments of the cost of implementation.
He questioned why universities were struggling financially and maintained that policymakers must examine the fundamentals before introducing changes to curricula or education funding arrangements.
“Why are we where we are?Where every university owes.
When you’re doing changes in any curriculum or in any policy of the government , look at fundamentals,what is the cost of a student having to go to university for 3 years or 4 years.
You’re supposed to do piloting,you check the dangers and come up with how you can medicate.
There must be independence of institutions,allowing institutions to operate.”
Kirwa called for pilot programmes before nationwide implementation of major education reforms, arguing that institutions should be given the independence to operate and identify practical solutions to their challenges.

LEADERSHIP AND GOVERNANCE
Beyond healthcare and education, Ademba challenged Kenya’s leadership to embrace institutional discipline, invest in research and adopt long-term policies that can survive changes in political leadership.
He questioned why Kenya frequently cites Singapore as a development model without examining the institutional discipline, research investment and governance structures that have contributed to the country’s progress.
Ademba argued that research should play a central role in shaping national policies, particularly in critical sectors such as health, education and justice.
“Kenya talking of Singapore,why are we not talking about the discipline in the institutions and the research that was put in place to make it to where it is.
For example if we do research in institutions around health, education and justice that we need to have discipline.
Discipline in leadership,in the research; research is a bigger part for Singapore to be where it’s and research should be a bigger part of when we are making policy and guidance for the next 60 years.
The institution must fail us when we don’t have discipline, presidents will come and go but if we have the discipline that is going to guide us that no matter who comes in we are still going to work with these guiding principles until we achieve it.
Let’s talk about why vision 2030 failed ,what worked and what didn’t give us the review at least.
We don’t use data partially but we use data politically,we don’t use research to solve solutions but we use research to win elections not to implement them that’s the problem of Kenya.”
Ademba further criticised the political use of research and data, arguing that evidence should guide policy implementation and problem-solving rather than being used primarily to advance electoral interests.
Former Cabinet Minister Kipruto Arap Kirwa emphasised the importance of respecting state institutions, including the Judiciary, Parliament and constitutional commissions established under the 2010 Constitution.
He argued that institutional independence and adherence to constitutional values are essential in ensuring that public services are delivered to all Kenyans, regardless of their social or economic status.
“Respect of the institutions of state, whether it’s judiciary, parliament or other institutions of state constitutional and land commissions or many other commissions that are enshrined in the 2010 constitution that’s the fundamental issue.
Human resource is the most important resource for Kenya and when the human resource is operating as per the values in the constitution,A Kenyan must be served irregardless of their status in life,age,or financial capacity
.A Leader should now be able to explain why they don’t want to ditch the policies that have been raided before instead of explaining what is new ,what they bring and why can’t they work on them.
We have confused things which are personal issues to policy issues” Former cabinet minister Kipruto Arap Kirwa
Hon. Kirwa maintained that strong institutions should provide continuity in governance and ensure that public servants remain guided by constitutional principles irrespective of the individuals occupying political offices.
THE END

